Shiller PE Ratio
The Shiller PE ratio uses 10-year average inflation-adjusted earnings to value markets, smoothing cyclical fluctuations for long-term investment decisions.
Key Takeaways
- →The Shiller PE averages ten years of inflation-adjusted earnings, providing more reliable market valuation than traditional PE ratios.
- →Current Shiller PE above 25 historically signals overvalued markets with higher risk of poor ten-year returns ahead.
- →Use Shiller PE to time market entry and exit decisions, buying when ratios are low, reducing exposure when high.
- →Unlike regular PE ratios, Shiller PE smooths earnings volatility from business cycles, recessions, and temporary profit spikes.
- →Track Shiller PE trends quarterly through CAPE data to identify long-term value opportunities in Australian and global markets.
Historical US Average
~17
Dot-Com Bubble Peak
~44 (Dec 1999)
Earnings Window
10-year inflation-adjusted average
Developed By
Robert Shiller, Yale University
Nobel Prize Year
2013 (Economics)
Key Limitation
Doesn't account for interest rate levels
What is Shiller PE Ratio?
The Shiller Price-to-Earnings (PE) Ratio, also known as the Cyclically Adjusted Price Earnings (CAPE) ratio, is a valuation metric that measures the price of a stock market relative to the average of its earnings per share over the previous 10 years, adjusted for inflation. Developed by Nobel Prize-winning economist Robert Shiller, this ratio aims to eliminate the noise of short-term earnings fluctuations that can distort traditional PE ratios, providing a more stable and meaningful assessment of market valuation.
Unlike the standard PE ratio, which uses current or forward earnings, the Shiller PE smooths out the business cycle effects by incorporating a full decade of earnings data. This approach recognises that corporate earnings are inherently cyclical, with periods of exceptional growth followed by contractions. By averaging these fluctuations over a longer timeframe, the metric provides investors with a clearer picture of whether markets are fundamentally overvalued or undervalued relative to their long-term earning capacity.
The ratio has gained significant prominence among institutional investors, financial analysts, and market strategists as a tool for assessing broad market conditions and informing long-term investment decisions. Its effectiveness lies in its ability to identify periods of extreme market valuations that traditional metrics might miss, making it particularly valuable for investors focused on market timing and asset allocation strategies across different economic cycles.
How Does Shiller PE Ratio Work?
The Shiller PE ratio calculation involves several key steps that differentiate it from conventional valuation metrics. First, analysts collect the nominal earnings per share data for the relevant stock market index over the previous 10 years. These earnings figures are then adjusted for inflation using the Consumer Price Index (CPI), converting them to real terms in current currency values. This inflation adjustment ensures that the earnings comparison remains meaningful across different economic periods characterised by varying levels of price inflation.
Once the inflation-adjusted earnings are calculated, they are averaged over the 10-year period to create a smoothed earnings base. The current market price is then divided by this average real earnings figure to produce the Shiller PE ratio. For example, if the current S&P 500 index level is 4,000 and the 10-year average of inflation-adjusted earnings per share is 100, the Shiller PE would be 40.
The methodology addresses several limitations of traditional PE ratios. Standard PE ratios can be misleading during periods of peak earnings (making markets appear cheaper than they are) or during earnings troughs (making markets appear more expensive). The 10-year averaging process captures complete business cycles, including both recession and expansion phases, providing a more balanced perspective on the relationship between prices and underlying economic productivity.
Interpretation of the Shiller PE requires understanding its historical context. Values significantly above the historical average typically suggest overvaluation, while readings well below the mean may indicate undervaluation. However, structural changes in economies, monetary policies, and market dynamics mean that absolute levels must be considered alongside secular trends and comparative analysis across different markets and time periods.
Historical Context
Robert Shiller first introduced the cyclically adjusted price earnings concept in the 1980s, but it gained widespread attention following the publication of his book "Irrational Exuberance" in 2000. The timing proved prescient, as the metric had been signalling extreme overvaluation in US equity markets throughout the late 1990s dot-com bubble. Historical analysis of the Shiller PE reveals its effectiveness in identifying major market turning points, though not necessarily their precise timing.
The highest Shiller PE reading on record occurred in December 1999, when the ratio reached approximately 44 for the S&P 500, well above its long-term average of around 17. This extreme reading preceded the significant market correction of 2000-2002. Similarly, elevated readings in the mid-to-late 1920s preceded the 1929 crash and subsequent Great Depression. Conversely, extremely low readings in the early 1980s and again in 2009 coincided with the beginning of major bull markets.
The metric's track record extends beyond US markets, with researchers applying the methodology to international equity markets with varying degrees of success. European markets, particularly those in the UK and Germany, have shown similar patterns, though emerging markets often display different characteristics due to their shorter historical data sets and different economic development stages.
One notable limitation revealed through historical analysis is the metric's inability to time market peaks and troughs precisely. Markets can remain overvalued or undervalued according to the Shiller PE for extended periods. The US market, for instance, appeared overvalued by this metric for much of the 1990s, yet continued rising for years before the eventual correction. This has led to the development of complementary analytical frameworks that incorporate the Shiller PE alongside other fundamental and technical indicators.
Current Relevance for Investors
Investors can apply Shiller PE analysis both domestically and internationally to inform their investment strategies. For the Australian market, historical Shiller PE data suggests the ASX has typically traded at lower multiples than US markets, partly reflecting Australia's resource-heavy composition and different economic cycles. The Australian Shiller PE has ranged from approximately 10-25 over recent decades, with peaks often coinciding with mining booms and commodity super-cycles.
The metric proves particularly valuable for Investors considering international diversification. US market Shiller PE levels above 30, as experienced in recent years, have historically preceded periods of below-average returns over subsequent decades. This analysis might inform decisions about geographic allocation within equity portfolios, potentially favouring markets with more attractive Shiller PE readings such as certain European or emerging market indices.
Currency considerations add complexity for Investors using Shiller PE analysis internationally. The strength of the Australian dollar relative to other currencies can significantly impact returns from foreign investments, potentially offsetting advantages identified through valuation metrics. Sophisticated investors often incorporate currency-hedged positions or consider real exchange rate adjustments when applying Shiller PE analysis to international investment decisions.
Contemporary applications of the Shiller PE must account for structural changes in global economies, including lower interest rates, technological disruption, and evolving corporate profit margins, which may justify different valuation levels than historical norms suggest.
Australian superannuation funds and institutional investors increasingly incorporate Shiller PE analysis into their strategic asset allocation decisions. The long-term nature of superannuation investing aligns well with the metric's focus on identifying multi-year valuation cycles. Fund managers use the ratio to adjust equity allocations, potentially reducing exposure during periods of extreme overvaluation and increasing exposure when markets appear undervalued relative to historical norms.
Warning Signs & Common Mistakes
Several critical mistakes can undermine the effectiveness of Shiller PE analysis for investment decision-making. The most common error involves treating the metric as a precise timing tool rather than a broad valuation gauge. Markets can remain overvalued or undervalued according to the Shiller PE for years, making it unsuitable for short-term trading strategies. Investors who sold US equities in the mid-1990s based solely on elevated Shiller PE readings missed substantial subsequent gains, demonstrating the importance of considering multiple analytical perspectives.
Another significant pitfall involves ignoring structural economic changes that may affect the appropriate baseline for comparison. The modern era of lower interest rates, technological innovation, and globalised supply chains may justify different Shiller PE levels than historical averages suggest. Blindly applying historical mean reversion assumptions without considering contemporary economic conditions can lead to systematic allocation errors.
Cross-country comparisons using Shiller PE ratios require careful consideration of different accounting standards, market structures, and economic development levels. Emerging market Shiller PEs, for instance, may not be directly comparable to developed market ratios due to shorter data series, different business cycle characteristics, and varying levels of market efficiency. Investors comparing ASX valuations to US market levels must account for sectoral composition differences and the unique influence of commodity cycles on Australian corporate earnings.
Data quality issues represent another area of concern, particularly for markets with limited historical depth or changing index compositions. The survivorship bias inherent in long-term index construction can inflate historical earnings averages, potentially making current valuations appear more expensive than they actually are. Additionally, changes in corporate tax rates, accounting standards, and reporting requirements over the 10-year averaging period can distort the metric's accuracy.
Finally, investors must avoid the mistake of using Shiller PE analysis in isolation from other fundamental and technical indicators. The most effective applications combine the metric with analysis of monetary policy conditions, yield curve dynamics, credit markets, and momentum indicators to develop comprehensive market assessment frameworks.
Key Takeaways
The Shiller PE ratio serves as a valuable long-term valuation tool that helps investors identify periods of extreme market over- or undervaluation by smoothing short-term earnings volatility through 10-year averaging and inflation adjustment. Its historical track record demonstrates effectiveness in identifying major market turning points, though precise timing remains elusive. Investors benefit from applying this analysis both domestically and internationally, recognising that local market characteristics and currency effects require careful consideration.
Successful implementation requires understanding the metric's limitations and avoiding common pitfalls such as using it for short-term timing or ignoring structural economic changes. The ratio works best as part of a comprehensive analytical framework rather than a standalone decision-making tool. Contemporary applications must consider the impact of low interest rates, technological disruption, and evolving market structures on appropriate valuation benchmarks.
For long-term investors, particularly those managing superannuation assets or other retirement savings, the Shiller PE provides valuable insights into strategic asset allocation decisions. Periods of extreme readings may warrant adjustments to equity exposure levels, geographic allocation, or risk management strategies. However, investors must maintain discipline and patience, recognising that value-oriented strategies based on cyclical metrics like the Shiller PE may underperform for extended periods before ultimately proving successful.
The metric's enduring relevance lies in its foundation on fundamental economic relationships between asset prices and underlying productivity. While specific numerical benchmarks may evolve with changing economic conditions, the core insight that markets periodically deviate significantly from fair value remains valid, making the Shiller PE an essential component of sophisticated investment analysis for professional and individual investors alike.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Shiller PE ratio and how does it work for ASX investing?
The Shiller PE ratio, or CAPE (Cyclically Adjusted Price Earnings), divides current ASX market prices by 10-year average inflation-adjusted earnings. This smooths out business cycle fluctuations that can distort traditional PE ratios. For Australian investors, it provides a longer-term valuation perspective on ASX sectors and the broader market, helping identify overvalued or undervalued periods.
How do I calculate Shiller PE for Australian stocks and market sectors?
Calculate Shiller PE by dividing current ASX stock price by the average of 10 years' inflation-adjusted earnings per share. Use RBA inflation data to adjust historical earnings to current dollars. While individual stock calculations require extensive data, ASX sector indices often publish CAPE ratios. Consider using established financial data providers for accurate Australian market Shiller PE calculations.
What are the main advantages and risks of using Shiller PE for Australian investment decisions?
The key advantage is smoothing earnings volatility, particularly useful during ASX mining cycles or economic downturns. However, Shiller PE can remain elevated or depressed for extended periods, making timing difficult. It also doesn't account for structural changes in Australian industries or RBA monetary policy impacts. Use alongside other valuation metrics for comprehensive analysis.
When should Australian investors use Shiller PE ratio in their investment strategy?
Use Shiller PE for long-term asset allocation decisions, particularly when entering or exiting ASX positions during apparent market extremes. It's valuable for comparing historical Australian market valuations and timing systematic investment plans. However, avoid using it for short-term trading or individual stock selection. Consider it alongside RBA economic outlook and sector-specific fundamentals.
Recommended
Key Statistics
Historical US Average
~17
Dot-Com Bubble Peak
~44 (Dec 1999)
Earnings Window
10-year inflation-adjusted average
Developed By
Robert Shiller, Yale University
Nobel Prize Year
2013 (Economics)
Key Limitation
Doesn't account for interest rate levels



